Insider threat
A current or former employee or contractor is the suspect. Protect the evidence and the organization's legal position first. Bring in HR and the Legal advisor before anyone touches the subject's accounts.
- Brief HR, the Legal advisor and a named leadership sponsor before any evidence collection.Incident Commander
- List the actions that need Legal advisor approval.Legal advisor
- Set the need-to-know list and keep the subject's manager and peers off it unless the Legal advisor approves.Incident Commander
- Confirm the subject's employment status with HR: notice, leave, open disciplinary matters.Liaison
- Decide covert or overt with HR and the Legal advisor and record it in T3.Incident Commander
- Place a legal hold on the subject's mailbox, file storage and cloud accounts before disabling any account.Legal advisor
Then work the page: Before investigating, Covert or overt, Scope, Evidence for litigation.
The subject has authorized access and knows internal systems and processes, so malicious activity looks like normal work and the insider can evade controls you rely on.
Premature technical action can tip off the subject, destroy evidence, and expose the organization to wrongful termination claims. HR and the Legal advisor set the pace. The Incident Commander runs the technical work inside the limits they set, and every finding is written for a possible court.
This page adds to the phase playbooks for scope, contain, eradicate and recover.
Chapter 13, p. 315. Chapter 7, p. 132.
What is different
Chapter 7, pp. 132 to 133. Chapter 13, pp. 316 to 317.
| Fact about the subject | Effect on the response |
|---|---|
| Resignation or notice already given | The exfiltration window is closing. Plan to act before the last day. |
| Administrator or developer access | Expect remote access tools, secondary accounts, or modified configurations that outlive the primary credentials |
| New hire, especially remote | Treat as possible from day one. In the 2024 KnowBe4 case, restricted access for new employees kept a hired North Korean operator away from company data. |
| Access to regulated or customer data | The Legal advisor decides on regulatory reporting and law enforcement referral early, because both change how evidence is handled |
Before investigating
Complete this before collecting evidence or touching the subject's accounts. HR is not a position in the command structure, so the Liaison carries HR's input into the incident. Rehearse it with the insider data breach scenario in the UK NCSC Exercise in a Box, which lists an HR advisor among the attendee roles.
Chapter 13, p. 315. Chapter 7, pp. 95, 103 to 104.
| # | Item | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Brief HR, the Legal advisor and a named leadership sponsor before any evidence collection | Incident Commander |
| 2 | List the actions that need Legal advisor approval, and what may be shared with whom | Legal advisor |
| 3 | Set the need-to-know list, and keep the subject's manager and peers off it unless the Legal advisor approves | Incident Commander |
| 4 | Confirm the planned monitoring is covered by the acceptable use policy, the login banner and applicable law, including data protection and labor agreements where they apply | Legal advisor |
| 5 | Exclude personal devices and personal accounts from collection unless the Legal advisor approves in writing | Legal advisor |
| 6 | Confirm the subject's employment status with HR: notice, leave, open disciplinary matters | Liaison |
| 7 | Decide whether counsel directs the investigation to protect privilege | Legal advisor |
Covert or overt
Decide the posture with HR and the Legal advisor, and record it in T3 Containment decision record.
In the book's Meridian Financial example, a senior accountant who had resigned showed data staging. IT quietly disabled his remote access, citing a routine security update. The legal team drafted a legal hold notice, and HR had administrative leave paperwork ready to execute if the investigation confirmed malicious activity.
Chapter 7, pp. 132 to 133.
| Posture | Use when | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Covert | The subject is unaware, evidence is still being gathered, and any ongoing loss can be limited quietly | Data may keep leaving. The team stays small and monitoring must stay within what the Legal advisor approved. |
| Overt | Data loss is active, there is a safety risk, or the subject already knows | The subject may destroy evidence or fall back on hidden access. Preserve evidence and cut every access path in the same action. |
Scope
Chapter 13, p. 316.
| # | Item | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Review data access, application access and cloud storage logs for access outside the subject's normal pattern | Intelligence/Investigations |
| 2 | List changes to the subject's accounts, group memberships and permissions, with dates | Intelligence/Investigations |
| 3 | Review email, cloud storage uploads, USB device connections and data loss prevention alerts for exfiltration | Intelligence/Investigations |
| 4 | Search systems for remote access tools, secondary accounts and modified configurations tied to the subject | Operations |
| 5 | List the shared, service and break-glass credentials the subject knew, for rotation | Operations |
Evidence for litigation
Insider cases frequently end in legal proceedings. Collect as if the evidence will be challenged, using the evidence collection procedures.
Chapter 13, p. 316. Chapter 7, p. 132.
| # | Item | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Place a legal hold on the subject's mailbox, file storage and cloud accounts before any account is disabled or deleted | Legal advisor |
| 2 | Collect and image the devices, record hash values, and start a chain of custody form at seizure | Intelligence/Investigations |
| 3 | Sequence HR's termination steps so device reissue, wiping and account deletion wait for preservation | Liaison |
| 4 | Record findings as observed facts with source log, timestamp and analyst name | Planning |
| 5 | Revoke every access path in one coordinated action timed to HR's meeting with the subject | Operations |
| 6 | Decide on law enforcement referral, and document the decision in T13 | Legal advisor |
- Premature technical action during an insider investigation can expose the organization to wrongful termination claims. Get HR and the Legal advisor in before the first account change.
- Standard termination procedures conflict with evidence preservation. A laptop wiped and reissued on the subject's last day is evidence lost.
- Revoking the primary account leaves any secondary accounts, remote access tools, and shared credentials the insider set up or knew. Scope for them before the overt action.